DFS mandates Gemini to refund $1.1B to Earn users and pay a $37M fine due to oversight failures.
The New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) has announced a landmark settlement with Gemini Trust Company, LLC, a leading cryptocurrency exchange and custodian. The enforcement action, led by Superintendent Adrienne A. Harris, obligates Gemini to return no less than $1.1 billion to customers of its Earn program, following its entanglement with the bankruptcy of Genesis Global Capital, LLC (GGC).
Gemini, co-founded by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, launched its Earn program on February 1, 2021, which permitted customers to lend their cryptocurrencies to GGC in exchange for interest payments. However, the platform faced significant setbacks when GGC defaulted on roughly $1 billion in loans from Earn customers, leading to a halt in withdrawals and subsequent bankruptcy filing.
Superintendent Harris underscored the lack of due diligence by Gemini on GGC, an unregulated third party, which culminated in substantial financial and reputational damage to over 200,000 Earn customers, including nearly 30,000 New Yorkers. The settlement emerges not only as a measure to rectify the harm done to these consumers but also as a warning to the crypto industry regarding the importance of regulatory compliance and the protection of customer assets.
As part of the settlement, Gemini will contribute $40 million to the GGC bankruptcy estate, in coordination with the Bankruptcy Court, to facilitate the return of assets to Earn customers. Furthermore, Gemini will incur a $37 million penalty due to a series of compliance failures that undermined the safety and soundness of its operations.
The DFS investigation revealed that Gemini’s Earn program was marred by inadequate oversight and reserves management. Moreover, Gemini Liquidity, LLC, an unregulated affiliate, was found to have siphoned hundreds of millions in customer fees that weakened Gemini’s financial standing. These revelations highlight the intricate web of financial and regulatory challenges that cryptocurrency entities face, especially as they intersect with traditional financial systems.
This development has rippling effects across the crypto landscape, as it underscores the rigorous stance regulatory bodies are taking towards compliance and consumer protection. The settlement serves as a precedent for the level of scrutiny and accountability that crypto platforms will likely encounter moving forward.
The DFS has affirmed its commitment to safeguarding the integrity of the financial market, ensuring that licensed entities like Gemini operate within the bounds of state regulations and in the best interest of their customers. This case also illustrates the complexities associated with virtual currency businesses and the need for clear regulatory frameworks to govern their operations.
The Gemini settlement is poised to restore consumer confidence in the platform and by extension, the broader crypto market, by demonstrating that regulatory bodies are actively working to protect investors’ interests. Additionally, it may prompt other crypto entities to proactively strengthen their compliance measures to avoid similar punitive actions.
Image source: Shutterstock