A Manhattan federal judge has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of criminal charges stemming from a 2023 Ethereum trading maneuver that prosecutors said extracted about $25 million. The ruling is significant, but its scope is narrow: the court found that prosecutors had not proved the material misrepresentations required for wire fraud and related convictions in this particular case.
The decision does not amount to judicial approval of every aggressive trading technique on public blockchains. Instead, it turns on the legal elements prosecutors needed to establish and the evidence presented at trial.
The disputed transactions
The case concerned maximal extractable value, or MEV, the ability to affect the ordering or inclusion of blockchain transactions for financial gain. Prosecutors said the brothers engineered a bait-and-switch involving Ethereum validator infrastructure and trading bots in April 2023. Their alleged manipulation diverted value that the bots otherwise expected to capture.
The defense contested the fraud theory. The unusual technical setting made the case a test of how existing criminal statutes apply to blockchain transactions that may be opportunistic or adversarial but do not necessarily resemble ordinary deceptive financial communications.
Why the judge entered an acquittal
US District Judge Jessica Clarke focused on whether the conduct, as charged and proved, met the legal requirements for fraud. According to reports of the ruling by Reuters and The Block, the relevant transactions did not involve material false representations of the kind prosecutors needed to establish.
The judge distinguished that legal test from the question of whether the behavior was fair, ethical or objectionable. She also noted the absence of a regulated-market rule prohibiting the charged conduct in that setting. An acquittal under particular charges does not pronounce on every possible theory of liability.
The case had already reached a mistrial
The brothers were arrested in May 2024, and a jury failed to reach a verdict in November 2025. That sequence matters when interpreting the ruling: the result followed substantial litigation rather than a quick dismissal immediately after an indictment.
The court’s reasoning offers a specific limit on a criminal fraud case, not a complete set of rules for MEV markets. Other facts, jurisdictions or statutory claims could produce different outcomes. Describing the ruling as the legalization of MEV attacks would overstate what the court decided.
Ethereum traders still face the underlying risk
MEV remains a practical concern for users who trade on-chain. Transaction ordering, block building and the design of trading bots can affect execution prices and who captures value. Better routing, slippage controls and protocol-level improvements may reduce some forms of extraction, but they do not eliminate competition over transaction priority.
Legal certainty matters for developers and traders, while consumer protection remains a separate operational issue. The industry will be watching how prosecutors and policymakers respond to the limits the judge identified.
A ruling on criminal liability also leaves open the technical question of how MEV infrastructure should be designed. Relays, builders and validators can change their software or operational policies, but those changes have different trade-offs for permissionlessness, censorship resistance and execution fairness.
Developers can study the facts of this case without treating the acquittal as a blanket endorsement of every form of transaction manipulation. The legal finding is narrower: the government did not prove the fraudulent representation required for the charged offences on the trial record.


