The Securities and Exchange Commission has frozen the assets of Indianapolis-based Backward Hat Capital and its two co-founders, Phillip Williams and Devin Johnson, alleging the firm operated a $560 million Ponzi scheme. The scheme targeted more than 2,000 investors beginning in July 2022.
A federal court granted a temporary restraining order and asset freeze following filings by the SEC, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, and federal prosecutors in New York. Kevin B. Duff was appointed as temporary receiver to oversee the companies and defendants' assets.
The Investment Pitch
Williams and Johnson sold limited partnership interests in private funds through a network of promoters, including to Williams's former investment advisory clients. They promised an AI-driven algorithm that would generate at least 6% monthly returns through foreign exchange trading. According to the SEC complaint, investor money would first be converted into a crypto asset before being deployed for that arbitrage.
From July 2022 to September 2025, approximately $210 million was raised. About $109 million was transferred to the fund's Coinbase account and converted to cryptocurrency. Of that amount, more than $56 million went to personal crypto accounts held by Williams, Johnson, and a relief defendant. Roughly $40 million was sent to three crypto platforms where little to no money was actually used for foreign exchange trading. After October 2025, the scheme raised approximately $350 million, none of which was sent to Coinbase.
Use of Funds
The SEC alleges that defendants made more than $250 million in Ponzi payments to earlier investors and transferred more than $220 million to themselves. According to the complaint, the money financed exotic cars, expensive homes, private air travel, other businesses, and Johnson's gambling activities. Promoters received more than $50 million.
Joseph Anderson is accused of producing fraudulent financial documents, including fake audit reports and a false quality of earnings report purportedly from an independent firm. The SEC said Anderson performed no audit work, was not independent, and had a financial interest in the scheme.
Legal Action
Prosecutors in Manhattan charged Williams and Johnson with securities fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit securities fraud. The FBI arrested Williams in Kokomo, Indiana, and Johnson in Gilbert, Arizona on Wednesday. Prosecutors estimate the total raised at more than $600 million.
The CFTC alleged the scheme raised more than $550 million from at least 2,100 participants, with defendants continuing to solicit funds through at least October 2026. Both the SEC and CFTC are seeking injunctions, disgorgement, and civil penalties. The CFTC also seeks trading bans and permanent injunctions.
Recent Enforcement Trend
The case follows other recent crypto-related fraud enforcement actions. The SEC charged two companies in a $130 million crypto trading scheme last month, New York pursued a $1.37 billion judgment against operators of the NovaTech Ponzi scheme, and in August the CFTC charged Goliath Ventures with a $400 million bitcoin fraud.


