Market desk Bitcoin Ethereum Altcoins DeFi Stablecoins Markets & Trading

Ethereum Glamsterdam Upgrade Tests Reveal Transactions Can Succeed While Internal Payments Fail

Simulations of the proposed Glamsterdam upgrade show cases where transactions complete successfully despite failing internal payments, including one instance where a cash-out occurred without paying a 2.5% fee.
1 hour ago 1 views
Ethereum Glamsterdam Upgrade Tests Reveal Transactions Can Succeed While Internal Payments Fail

Tests of Ethereum's proposed Glamsterdam upgrade have revealed a potential issue: transactions can report success while payments within them fail. Simulations run on the Sepolia test network using Juicebox V6 contracts identified four payment paths where this behavior occurs.

Developer mejango published the simulation results dated November 14. The tests used deployed contract code through a tool called eth_simulateV1, with each run launching a fresh project and testing payment paths across different transaction gas limits.

Payment Paths with Incomplete Execution

The four tested scenarios produced unexpected outcomes:

  • In a payout test, transactions succeeded while skipping a split meant for another project, leaving funds in the paying project instead
  • A reserved-token distribution completed despite a cross-project payment failing, with the beneficiary receiving raw tokens
  • A buyer retained an NFT while the related payment to another project failed, though the purchase still processed
  • In a cash-out test with gas limits between 679,622 and 817,622, withdrawals completed without paying a 2.5% fee

The developer attributed the difference to the order in which operations run out of gas. Under the tested rules, an internal payment that writes fresh storage can fail before the outer transaction exhausts its gas limit. The contract's try/catch error handling then absorbs that failure, allowing the surrounding operation to finish.

Comparison with Current Rules

When the same four payment paths were tested under current mainnet rules, they produced only two outcomes: transaction failure or complete delivery of all payments. No intermediate states occurred.

The results remain developer simulations that have not been independently reproduced. They cover tested paths and gas samples only, and no live incident has been reported on the network.

Technical Background and Timeline

The Glamsterdam upgrade includes EIP-8037, which proposes higher costs for creating persistent blockchain data and separates accounting for state creation and execution. EIP-8038 updates the costs of accessing and writing state. Together, these changes aim to support increased throughput while controlling resource demands.

Ethereum core developers are scheduled to discuss the findings and possible next steps on November 19. The Ethereum Foundation recommended reviewing public audit findings before deciding on specification changes or the Hoodi testnet schedule.

Market snapshot

Top cryptocurrency prices

Explore all prices
BitcoinBTC $64,707.32+0.20% EthereumETH $1,814.25+0.33% Tether USDUSDT $0.9991-0.09% BNBBNB $592.37+0.29% USDCUSDC $1.000.00% XRPXRP $0.9688+1.18% SolanaSOL $73.40+2.60% TRONTRX $0.3059+0.32% HyperliquidHYPE $69.17+3.73% ZcashZEC $945.08+6.03%
Prices by Coinranking. Informational only.